HISTORICAL VIEW AND EXPERIENCES WITH THE CRUSH TEST FOR LIGHT WEIGHT PACKAGES

Year
2010
Author(s)
Marko Nehrig - BAM Federal Institute for Materials Research and Testing Berlin, Germany
Frank Wille - BAM Federal Institute for Materials Research and Testing Berlin, Germany
Thomas Quercetti - BAM Federal Institute for Materials Research and Testing
Jörg-Peter Masslowski - BAM Federal Institute for Materials Research and Testing Berlin, Germany
Bernhard Droste - BAM Federal Institute for Materials Research and Testing Berlin, Germany
Ronald Pope - Consultant, USA
Abstract
The crush test for light weight and low density Type B packages was introduced for the first time into the 1985 edition of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) transport safety regulations. In the early 1970s the need for an additional mechanical test besides or instead of the well known 9 m drop test was deliberated. Various authors and test facilities, including BAM and Sandia National Laboratories (SNL), were able to prove that the level of safety provided by IAEA drop and puncture tests in the regulations did not protect against dynamic crush forces to smaller packages. As early as the 3rd PATRAM symposium held in 1971 (Richland/USA), Robert F. Barker asked for “…a more strenuous crushing test for protecting small, light weight packages…”. BAM developed from research activities a proposal as to which types of packages should be subject to crush tests and how the crush tests should be performed, which was presented on the 5th PATRAM symposium held in 1978 (Las Vegas/USA). At the IAEA, the possible need for a crush test was first mentioned in 1977. The subject for a discussion, besides the principal need for this test, was also the development of suitable set of crush test boundary conditions. It took more than four years of discussion until a dynamic crush test similar to today's test was recommended by experts to the IAEA regulatory revision panel. Finally, after a rigorous evaluation process in which also the boundary conditions were determined, the crush test was proposed to be incorporated into the IAEA regulations. BAM and SNL participated in the crush test development and implementation process right from the beginning in the early 1970s until its implementation in the IAEA regulations in 1985. Today, BAM performs crush test procedures according to para. 727 (c) of TS-R-1 [5], which have not been changed since their first implementation. Crush tests performed in 2002 at BAM will be discussed. These approval design tests were performed on birdcage pellet transport containers under normal and accident conditions according to the IAEA- Regulations.